Tuesday, August 08, 2006

Future of Islam in India

भारत में इस्लाम का भविष्य

मुम्बई बम विस्फोटों के बाद एक बार फिर यह चर्चा शुरू हो गई है कि क्या इसलाम ही आतंकवाद की जड़ में है? जनसाधारण में यह धारणा अब पक्की हो चुकी है कि भारत में चल रहे आतंकवाद की असली वजह इस्लाम ही है। वहीं कुछ इस्लामी विद्वानों का कहना है कि ऐसा कहना ग़लत है, इस्लाम अमन का मज़हब है। अगर क़ुरआन और शरीयत को देखें, तो यह पशोपेश अपने आप ही समाप्त हो जाता है। मैं किसी की आस्था को चोट नहीं पहुँचाना चाहता हूँ, लेकिन तथ्यों के आधार पर कहा जाए तो इस बात को कोई नहीं नकार सकता कि इस्लाम स्वभावत: कट्टर, आक्रामक और मध्ययुगीन है। क़ुरआन में विधर्मियों को जान से मारने का आदेश साफ़-साफ़ पढ़ा जा सकता है। इसी वजह से शुऐब जैसे पढ़े-लिखे और बुद्धिजीवी लोग इस्लाम से दूर हो रहे हैं।

ईसाईयत के बाद इस दुनिया में इस्लाम के अनुयायियों की संख्या सबसे ज़्यादा है। भारत में भी इस्लाम के अनुयायी भारी तादाद में रहते हैं। इनमें से ज़्यादातर ऐसे हैं, जिनका आतंकवाद से कोई सरोकार नहीं है और वे भी भारत को उसी तरह अपना देश मानते हैं, जिस तरह कि हिन्दू मानते हैं। इसलिए विश्व हिन्दू परिषद और बजरंगदल के ये कथन कि भारत में इस्लाम का ख़ात्मा किए जाने की ज़रूरत है, असम्भव ही नहीं बल्कि घातक भी हैं। इस्लाम के ख़ात्मे का मतलब होगा २० करोड़ इंसानों का ख़ात्मा, जो एक आमानुषिक कृत्य होगा। अगर भारत के सभी मुसलमानों के पन्थान्तरण की बात कही जाए, तो वह भी व्यावहारिक तौर पर असम्भव ही है।

भारत में इस्लाम की ऐसी दुविधापूर्ण स्थिति है, जिसके बारे में कहा जा सकता है कि न इसे उगला जा सकता है और न ही निगलना मुमकिन है। इस समस्या का बस एक ही समाधान नज़र आता है और वह है एक वैचारिक तौर पर आधुनिक और उदारवादी इस्लामी सम्प्रदाय का प्रसार। जो मध्ययुगीन और कट्टर विचारों से पूरी तरह मुक्त हो। जिस तरह यूरोप में कैथॉलिक कट्टरता से आज़ादी पाने के लिए प्रोटेस्टेंट पंथ का प्रचार किया गया था, ठीक उसी तरह की प्रक्रिया इस्लाम के लिए भी ज़रूरी है।

भारत में यह होना तो दुनिया के दूसरे हिस्सों की तुलना में ख़ासा आसान है। इसकी वजह है – भारतीय इस्लाम पर सूफ़ीवाद का गहरा प्रभाव और भारत में सूफ़ियों की लम्बी परम्परा का होना। सूफ़ीवाद और वेदान्त यानी कि तात्विक हिन्दू धर्म वैचारिक तौर पर एक कहे जा सकते हैं, दोनों में ज़रा भी फ़र्क़ नहीं है। अगर सूफ़ियों के कथनों पर ग़ौर किया जाए, तो उनकी अनुभूति हिन्दू सन्तों के से सैद्धान्तिक धरातल पर आ टिकती है। अगर ध्यान से देखा जाए, तो भारतीय इस्लाम अपने मूल स्वरूप में सूफ़ीवादी इस्लाम ही है। लेकिन कई ख़ासे आधुनिक ऐतिहासिक कारणों से यह अब अपना मूल चरित्र विस्मृ‍त कर चुका है। अगर भारत में इस्लाम को प्रगतिशील और उदारवादी होना है, तो इसके मूल सूफ़ीवादी चरित्र का पुनरुत्थान ज़रूरी है। इसके लिए न सिर्फ़ मुसलमानों को कोशिश करनी होगी, बल्कि हिन्दुओं को भी इसमें अपना पूरा सहयोग देना होगा। भारत में अगर इस्लाम फिर इस सूफ़ीवादी प्रभाव से सम्पन्न हो जाता है, तो बाक़ी की दुनिया के लिए यह एक सबक़ होगा और यह उदारवादी इस्लाम भारत से बाहर भी तेज़ी से फैल सकेगा।

आप लोगों की इस बारे में क्या राय है? क्या इस्लाम इस तरह उदारवादी और प्रगतिशील हो सकता है? या फिर इसका कोई और उपाय भी है?

टैग : ,

34 comments:

  1. Pratik Jee! Your thinking is probably in the right direction. But truly speaking I am not too hopeful about that!

    ReplyDelete
  2. प्रत्तीक,

    बात तो आप ने बिलकुल युक्तिसंगत कही है किन्तु मुल्ला मौलवियों को कौन समझएगा। सूफियों को तो कट्टर मुस्लिम heretical मानते हैं तभी मन्सूर जैसे सूफी सन्त को शूली पर चढ़ा दिया गया था, अनल हक़ (अहम् ब्रह्मास्मि) कहने पर।

    ReplyDelete
  3. Anonymous11:44 PM

    Hi Pratik,

    Your solution on paper is very impressive but as far as I have experienced I think Muslims blindly believe in Quran. Religious discussion with muslims can end only with bad feelings or worse.

    One time I asked a Muslim friend "Why Muhammad was pedophilic? and the answer was that he wanted to set an example in society what things are possible in the world". I wont say that this answer was representative to whole Muslim society but could not disagree too coz after all each of them have full faith in him.

    Moreover, Quran says explicitly that their is only one religion & that is "Muslim". Muslims are so strict abt their religion that its scary to talk abt religion with them.

    These issues have really affected each and every individual over the world and sadly nothing much can be done. We should better take care of bunch of fools sitting in Parliament who are encouraging them at the cost of our life.

    ReplyDelete
  4. प्रतीक जी,
    मै इस बात का विरोध करता हूं कि "जनसाधारण में यह धारणा अब पक्की हो चुकी है कि भारत में चल रहे आतंकवाद की असली वजह इस्लाम ही है।" मै मानता हूं कि शायद सारे आतंकवादी इस्लामिक होंगे, पर यह मानना बेहद भ्रामक होगा कि सारे इस्लामिक लोग आतंकवादी हैं।
    आपकी बात और सुझाव अच्छे हैं, इतिहास गवाह है कि समय के साथ साथ जो धर्म, जातियाँ, समाज अपने आप को नही बदलते, वे मिट जाते हैं। इस्लाम का भी लंबा इतिहास रहा है। देखना यही है कि ये कुछ कठमुल्लों की बपौती बनकर रह जाता है, या शोएब जैसे कुछ भाई इसे बदल पाते हैं।

    ReplyDelete
  5. बहुत सही लिखा प्रतीक जी, मेरा मानना भी अमूनन "गुमनाम" (तीसरी टिप्पणी) की तरह ही हैं। अगर इस्लाम बदलता है तो गैर-मुसलमानों के लिये यह सबसे खुशी की बात होगी - इसीलिये ये कहना गलत होगा कि इसमें मेरा स्वार्थ नही बल्कि मैं तो भीख माँगता हूँ रोज कि इस्लाम का विकास और प्रगति हो क्योंकि मेरी जिंदगी इस पर ही टिकी ही और मेरे हाथों मे कुछ नही बचा - पर अभी के आसारों के अनुसार ये शायद संभव नही। ना ही यह संभव है कि गैर-मुसलमान इतना नीचे गिरें कि इस्लाम के कट्टर पंथियों को किसी और तरीके से नष्ट कर सकें। मेरे अनुसार दुनिया का भविष्य मुसलमानों का आधिपत्य और बाकीयों की मौत है!

    ई-छाया जी: ये समझ में नही आया कि आप किस बात का विरोध करतें है? जनसाधारण अगर कुछ मानता है तो आपके विरोध से मानना बदल नही जायेगा। आप या हम नहीं मानते तो भी जनसाधारण अपन से भी बड़ा है। अंत में यदि ये भ्रामक भी है तो क्या? जनसाधारण भ्रामक बात मानता है पर मानता तो है ना।

    ReplyDelete
  6. प्रतीक बहुत सही बात उठायी है, इस्लाम को उदारवादी बनाने के लिये पहले मेरे ख्याल से मदरसे खत्म करने पड़ेंगे। इनसे इस्लाम को फायदा तो कुछ नही होता नुकसान ही होता दिख रहा है क्योंकि यहीं से कुरान के प्रति अंधभक्ति बढ़ती है।

    ReplyDelete
  7. आपने कहा भारत में उदारवादी मुस्लीम नजरीये का प्रचार प्रसार करना चाहिए, और यह भारत में आसान है। मैरा विचार है कि यह भारत में ही मुश्कील है। क्योंकि यहाँ के जनता के प्रतिनिधि यह होने नही देंगे और आम जनता अपनी दैनिन्दीनी की समस्याओं से उपर उठकर ऐसे भागीरथ प्रयासों मे सक्रिय योगदान नही देगी।

    देखा नही मुलायमसिन्ह क्या कर रहा है? यह लालु यादव जो अपनी चुनावी सभाओं में ओसामा के डुप्लीकेट को लिए फिरते हैं।

    ReplyDelete
  8. Anonymous10:01 PM

    WHY U ALL GUYS ARE SO DESPERATE TO CHANGE iSLAM AFTERALL ITS NOT YOUR FAITH. EVERYBODY IS FREE TO FOLLOW THEIR OWN RELIGION. I AM A MUSLIM IF I DONT HAVE NO PROBLEM WITH MY FAITH WHY U PEOPLE WORRIED SO MUCH ABOUT THAT. SEE LOTS OF GUYS HERE DONT EVEN KNOW BASICS OF ISLAM. ONE SAID MUSLIM RELIGION THERE IS NO MUSLIM RELIGION LOL
    ISLAM IS SIMPLE EITHER TAKE IT OR LEAVE IT IF YOU AGREE TO THE RULES OF ISLAM BE A MUSLIM IF NOT PRACTICE WHATEVER U WANT.
    IF SOME KNUCKLE HEAD MIS INTERPRET A VERSE OF QURAN ALL IDIOTS START COMMENTING ABOUT WORLDS FASTEST GROWING RELIGION WITHOUT ANY KNOWLEDGE.WHY THEY NEVER TALK ABOUT MANUSRUTI
    TELL ME ARE HINDU RELIGIOUS SCRIPTURES PROGRESSIVE OR DEMOCRATIC OR HUMANE ?
    WHY DO WE HAVE SCHEDULE CAST & TRIBES & BACKWARDS IN INDIA.
    WHO ARE THESE INDIAN MUSLIMS ?
    THE SAME PEOPLE WHO WAS OPRESSED FOR CENTURIES UNDER THIS OUTDATED IDEOLOGY. THEY WERE DOWNTRODDEN HINDUS AND THEY BECOME MUSLIMS BECAUSE ISLAM OFFERED EQUALITY AMONGST ALL THE HUMAN BEINGS & DIGNITY OF HUMAN LIFE.
    U GUYS NEED TO CHANGE YOUR DASI PRATHA , SATI PRATHA ,VARNA VYAVASTA THE LIST IS ENDLESS.
    ISLAM IS NOT FOR ONLY MUSLIM ITS FOR EVERYBODY. FOR US ALL ARE SAME.
    WE HAVE NO CASTE SYSTEM
    ISLAM IS THE FIRST RELIGION WHO SAID USE YOUR BRAIN IT TALKS ABOUT LOGIC & NOTHING BUT THE LOGIC.
    WE ARE OPEN FOR ANY DEBATE OR DISCUSSION COME WITH OPEN HEART AND WE WILL CONVINCE YOU BUT IF YOU ARE ONE OF THOSE PREJUDICIAL FOLK NOBODY CAN HELP U.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Anonymous5:42 PM

    can some body tell how to write blog in hindi

    ReplyDelete
  10. Anonymous5:57 PM

    To anonymous who replied at 10:01 am in BOLD LETTERS.

    "WHY U ALL GUYS ARE SO DESPERATE TO CHANGE iSLAM AFTERALL ITS NOT YOUR FAITH. EVERYBODY IS FREE TO FOLLOW THEIR OWN RELIGION."

    Because you kill other religions' innocent people with one hand on kuran and another with Gun or Bombs. because you can not tolerate other religions growing in prosperity and flourishing. "Because as per Quran Mohd is the only messenger of the God ( U repeat it five times a day forcibly from your mosques.) and all others are fake.". No other religion in the world proclaims and become aggressive as Islam to annihilate all other faiths. That is why we fear Islam.

    "I AM A MUSLIM IF I DONT HAVE NO PROBLEM WITH MY FAITH WHY U PEOPLE WORRIED SO MUCH ABOUT THAT."

    That is the problem with Islam. Only if you are inside Islam u do not have any problem. U declare now that you are leaving Islam and Allah will come with a sword to cut your throat and mullahs will issue Fatwahs against you. That is the problem.

    "SEE LOTS OF GUYS HERE DONT EVEN KNOW BASICS OF ISLAM. ONE SAID MUSLIM RELIGION THERE IS NO MUSLIM RELIGION LOL"

    You need not study Islam basics to differentiate between Life and Death. Islam is associated with death ( Cruel and inhuman deaths) and there is no life in it except aggressions, inequality, murders, rapes, honour killings, multiple wives, forcible conversions.

    "ISLAM IS SIMPLE EITHER TAKE IT OR LEAVE IT IF YOU AGREE TO THE RULES OF ISLAM BE A MUSLIM IF NOT PRACTICE WHATEVER U WANT."

    Islam is simple: Either take Islam or Hell (Death).You accept it or prepared to die since there is no other messenger to Allah than Mohammed.(PBUH). Peace be upon him since he commits all sorts of nonpeaceful activities on humankind.

    "IF SOME KNUCKLE HEAD MIS INTERPRET A VERSE OF QURAN ALL IDIOTS START COMMENTING ABOUT WORLDS FASTEST GROWING RELIGION WITHOUT ANY KNOWLEDGE"

    You are showing the real intolerable face of Islam in this site by addressing other human beings as Knuckle Heads, Idiots etc., (since Islam is the only religion and you people should not question it.).It is the fastest growing and fastest depleting religion in the world. ( See in Iraq, pakistan, Afghanistan Muslims are killing Muslims and which side are you? Wahabi, Sunni, Ahmediya, Sufi or Pagan muslim. (Joke: One indian muslim sect chief issued a fatwa against Osama Bin Ladan for acting against Islam. So which is real Islam.

    "WHY THEY NEVER TALK ABOUT MANUSRUTI
    TELL ME ARE HINDU RELIGIOUS SCRIPTURES PROGRESSIVE OR DEMOCRATIC OR HUMANE ?"

    No Hinduism does take the smritis word by word as you muslims take it. There were four castes in those times namely Brahmins( who is specialists in Worships.) The Kshatriyas ( who fight), Vaisya ( those who trade) and Shudras ( those who work for others). If you see the current world also it is almost the same professions we all have. But today a Shudra can also worship like a Brahman, and he can fight in Army, or trade and do the work for others and other companies. Hinduism has developed to such a Great extent that people know how to interpret the scriptures to current times.

    WHY DO WE HAVE SCHEDULE CAST & TRIBES & BACKWARDS IN INDIA.
    WHO ARE THESE INDIAN MUSLIMS ?

    The people who were on the lower category of the socail strata are SCs and STs and they are everywhere in the world. Like cobblers, washermen, Watchmen, Housemaids, etc., Now other castes are also doing these works and social strata is changing.

    (The society has to be directed by Intellectuals, Law enforcers, Business community, and workers.)

    Now every caste in India are doing every work of other castes,

    A counter question? Why Shias are killing Sunnis? Bin laden is trying to over throw Saudi Regime? Bugti is killed by musharaf? Nawab Sharif is thrown out by Musharraf? Bhutto is hanged by Yahya Khan? Hizbollah is opposed by Saudis? Is it fast growing or fast depleting?

    THE SAME PEOPLE WHO WAS OPRESSED FOR CENTURIES UNDER THIS OUTDATED IDEOLOGY. THEY WERE DOWNTRODDEN HINDUS AND THEY BECOME MUSLIMS BECAUSE ISLAM OFFERED EQUALITY AMONGST ALL THE HUMAN BEINGS & DIGNITY OF HUMAN LIFE.

    The same people who are ignorant of their religion and roots will join your Islam which is founded by a Child raper Mohammed who used to have more than 16 wives. ( One of 6 years old, One is his daughter in Law. One a wife of Jew who was murdered same day forced to lie on bed with him.)

    "U GUYS NEED TO CHANGE YOUR DASI PRATHA , SATI PRATHA ,VARNA VYAVASTA THE LIST IS ENDLESS."

    We have already changed and we have adopted the good values from the old systems.

    "ISLAM IS NOT FOR ONLY MUSLIM ITS FOR EVERYBODY. FOR US ALL ARE SAME.
    WE HAVE NO CASTE SYSTEM
    ISLAM IS THE FIRST RELIGION WHO SAID USE YOUR BRAIN IT TALKS ABOUT LOGIC & NOTHING BUT THE LOGIC."

    Your door is open for everybody. But once inside you have to kill Shias, Infidels, atatck them wherever they are. Your rule is one for Muslims and another for Infidels or Kaffirs.

    But rule is different for Shias, Sunnis, Wahabis, Ahmediyas and Thaliban. Thaliban kills you if you play football. Pakistan kills you if you fail in cricket. Kasmairis pour acid on Girls if the Purdah is not put. And lot of Fatwas, anti fatwas etc., etc., It is all in turmoil. Quran is dead. You cannot find your answers in Quran. It is death for all.

    "WE ARE OPEN FOR ANY DEBATE OR DISCUSSION COME WITH OPEN HEART AND WE WILL CONVINCE YOU BUT IF YOU ARE ONE OF THOSE PREJUDICIAL FOLK NOBODY CAN HELP U."

    There is no need of discussions and debates since September 11, London Bombings, Kashmir massacres, Besln children murders, Iraq, Afganistan, Taliban are all in front of us. You cannot discuss a cult with death from the birth as their hallamark.

    ReplyDelete
  11. प्रतीक भाई, आपकी ये वाली पोस्ट यहां डाली गई है।

    ReplyDelete
  12. Anonymous2:29 PM

    i can say that, discussions like tHIS will increase the misunderstandings and problems. please don't write these type of articles to attract people on your blogs.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Khalid7:25 PM

    First of all i am happy to find Hindi blog and so many nice and mature users. Most of the blog articles are very nice and the bloggers have commented carefully without hurting each other. However there were some comments on Islam for which i have some concerns. Although i am not hurt but i think i must clarify to my capacity. First of all let me tell you I am not a fanatic or blind believer of the religion. But I love the religion which I am associated with. Also, I do condemn the various acts of violence committed by Muslims (especially Pakistani in India and their own country - who have made our life hell). I do not want to go in the details on how people becomes terrorists but one thing is sure that we have terrorist from every faith or who had associated themselves with every religion like Islam, Christianity (IRA), Hindus (LTTE) and Sikhs (Punjab in 80s).

    I do not want to degrade any religion or faith but I do believe that differences can be resolved if moderate people of religion join together.


    Dear brothers - Muslims blindly believe in Quran but actually its now true (except for those who are illiterate). Actually there is nothing in Quran which can be believed blindly, everything is based on reason and logic. I would request you to kindly visit following website and find out yourselves.

    1) www.harunyahya.com

    2) http://www.islam-guide.com/

    Quran does not say that the only religion is "Muslim". Muslim is not the religion. Muslims are the follower of religion called Islam. Quran does not say that the Prophet Mohammed (pbuh) was the only messenger of God. Actually quran names many other prophets clearly such as Adam , Idris (Enoch), Nuh (Noah), Hud (Eber), Saleh (Shelah), Ibrahim (Abraham), Lut (Lot), Ismail (Ishmael), Ishaq (Isaac), Yaqub (Jacob), Yusuf (Joseph), Ayub (Job), Shoaib (Jethro), Musa (Moses), Harun (Aaron), Dhul-Kifl (most likely Ezekiel), Dawood (David), Sulayman (Solomon), Ilyas (Elijah), Al-Yasa (Elisha), Yunus (Jonah), Zakariya (Zacharias), Yahya (John the Baptist) and Isa ibn Maryam (Jesus).

    Moreover, Quran clearly says that 1) God has sent his messengers to all the nations on the earth 2) and that no body will be sent to hell or held accountable until a clear warner / messenger has come to him.

    There is nothing to be scared about talking or discussing about our religion as long as your intention is not to hurt by saying the harsh words e.g I may ask you politely why lord Krishna had several wives or i can also ask the same question in abusive way. So i think it depends upon on how you ask your question or raise your concern.

    Jai Hind

    ReplyDelete
  14. Anonymous5:53 PM

    Wow! I can understand if western Chrisitans or evn Jews commented on Islam like this but from people who don't even take baths. Gosh! I have studied different religions but hinduism has to be the sorse. Worshipping rats, drinking piss,worshipping statues. Hinduism is more spooky and creepy to me than Islam. Atleast the muslims take baths and believe in One Goad and Jesus Christ. Dissed by a hindu. Thats like being insulted from a raoch

    ReplyDelete
  15. I guess we all so called padhe likhe log would be willing agree that no religion is perfect in this world, like no man is. The very Goal or objective of all the religions is to make man perfect in terms of healthy mind, body and soul. I dont understand how can someone think of any other religion as so inhumane, if there would have been any such religion in this world it wouldnt even have lasted a day as noone could have believed in it. Mahabharta is story of continuous fraud and violence and Krishna's sayings are about killing your brother if he is liable to be killed type. Do we think that is inhumane? It all comes to one thing, what is the frame you are holding to look at the things the higher you can think of the clearer the view becomes. The very concept of God tells that there is only one God otherwise we will have different gods fighting each other proving them to be no more Gods.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Anonymous12:49 AM

    pehle to me uon sab jo islam ke khilaf ya islam ko badalne ki sonchte hai. pagal ya jahil kahunga. islam oun ke baap ki jaayedaat nahi jise wo jab chahe badal de. are jo apene khud ke dharm me peda hue hai usko hi barabar nahi jante aur chale islam ko badal ne.... me batana chahunga islam kaya hai.... islam es duniya aur es jesi jitni bhi duniya hai uspar rehne walo ke kiye allah (god) ne khud utara hai. jise me nahi woh (god) khud challenge karta hai ki tum ensaan aur jin (sprit/hollow) milkar bhi aysi chees banasakte aur na hi esi badal sakte ho.
    islam ne jo aur jahaa sakhtiya batai hai wanhi rehem ki guhar bhi lagai hai. esliye ye sonch badldo ki tum ya ko RSS/BJP ke khuch us paak Quraan ka ek nukta bhi badal paoge. kuch matalab parast muslim jo name ke hai unke liye islam par ungli uthana chod do......
    i am Pround to be a Muslim.
    ALLAH HO AKBAR

    ReplyDelete
  17. Anonymous3:56 PM

    pratik ne kaha islam me badlav ki zaroorat hai.use ye baat pehle samajhani hogi,"The imperfect is needed changes like ur religion where so many things like sati pratha it has changed by raja ram mohan rao. because it was imperfect.u quoted one line of quran that it teaches fighting.u should go through ur scripture mahabharat which shows how to kill urs own" i think before pointing out others u should .........!

    ReplyDelete
  18. Anonymous3:42 PM

    Actually all the religions are best but the worst things are followers because we are always trying to take personal benifits on the name of our religion. Yes Islam is in danger but from whom......... form terrorist only not from anyone else. They told we are muslims and god send us to save islam but they don't know the MEANING of ISLAM. God is not so cheap that he will comes in their dreams and ask them to save anything, God is so powerfull who can do anything by its own. So Don't critisize any community, critisize only wrong things.

    ReplyDelete
  19. pratik ji
    aap ki bato se me poori tarah sahmat hu.lekin muslmano ki katarta hi aam logo se unko alag karti hai? me yah nahi kahta ki sare muslman aatakbadi hai lekin a jaroor kahta hu ki marne bala har aatankbadi muslman jaroor hai.

    ReplyDelete
  20. Anonymous12:15 AM

    wah.........hindu kitne mahan hain...ki apno se jyada dosron ke bare me sochte hain......dalit mandir me nahin ja sakta kiyon ......kiyonki wo nichli jati ka hai.....kya wo hindu nahin..kya ooska bhagwaan alag hai..........khir ab pate ki toom logon ne likha quraan me maar kaat ka jikar hai...kya koi batayega ye quran me kaun si jagah par likha huwa hai....ab baat atankwaad ki .kya hai atankwaad,,,,haq ki ladai ko toom atankwaad kahte ho....kya ram atanwadi tha jisne rawan se sita ke liye yudh kiya.......kya mahabharat poori atankwaad par adharit hai........kya hinduon ne begunah logon ka khoon nahin bahaya hai..ek insaan ki galti ko poore kom se jodte ho.....yahi hai toomhari soch jab toomhare dil me hamare liye itnee nafrat hai to hum se kya oomeed rakhte ho.....hum toomhari ji hajoori karen kiyoonki toom abadi me hum se jyada ho..........toom hame maroge.......pahle apne girebaan me jhanko.....hindustaan me hinduon ne 1938 se lekar ab tak 8 million musalmano ka qatal kiya hai.....ye iss liye nahin ki toom bahoot bahadoor ho balke issliye ki kamzooron par bahadoori dikhano toomhari aadat hai.......doosron ko darane wala mahan nahin hota......khair toomhara ishara kashmir ki taraf hai ke wahan ke log atankwadi hain.........kabhi oonka dard toom ne dekha hai....onke bete ko hindustani fauj ghar se le jakar jungle me marti hai aur bolti hai ye atankwadi tha......poochne wala kaun hai ye kon tha.........toomhare samne tomhara ghar jalaya jaye toomhare ma bahno ki izzat looti jaye.......kaisa lagega .ji paoge..........hindustaan me kitne dange huwe iska andaza hai.......gujraat me train jalane walon ko saza dene ke bazaye..pori kom ko jalaya ..yahi hai toomhara dharam.........ek ka badla poori kom se..wo bhi issliye ki wo kamzor hai .toomhare mulk me..tomhara muqabla nahi kar sakta......toom 100 aur wo 20......nikal liye bahaduri dikhane........india se bahar aur kahin toomhari bahodoori nahin chalti....MUSALMANO SE ITNI NAFRAT HAI KI MITANE KI BAAT KARTE HO.........70 PERCENT INDIAN ECONOMY MUSALMAN CUNTRY SE CHALTA HAI ......HUME KAHTE HO PAKISTAN JAO KIYON BHAI......BAHANA ACHCHA HAI.....NAFRAT SE NA KOI JITA HAI NA JITEGA.......KHIR EK SACHHE HINDU HONE KE NATE APNE DHARM KO JANO...OOSPAR AMAL KARO..........TOMHARE DIL SE DUSRON KE LIYE NAFRAT APNE AAP NIKAL JAYEGI..........KOI DHARM KHRAB NAHIN HOTA...........DHARM KO MANNE WALON KI SOCH SAHI HONI CHAHIYE......WAISE MAIN YE BATA DOON MAIN PAKISTANI NAHIN HINDUSTANI MUSALMAN HOON........AUR EK MUSALMAN HONE KI WAJAH SE JITNA TAQLIF OOTHAYA HOON MAIN HI JANTA HOON.......

    ReplyDelete
  21. Anonymous4:47 PM

    pratik tum pagal ho hume mitane ke bat karto ho. bewkhuf hindostan ko ajad kaun karaya, jis lal kile me rashtrapati rahata hai kaun banaya. yaha ke logo ko to khane, pehanne ka tarika bhi nahi tha, ghas khate the, nange ghumte the yakin nahi ata to adivasi logo me muslim dhond kar batao, sabhi tumhe hindu hi melege. aur bat karte ho humko badle ke, hamare kuran ko galat kahto ho, lanat ho tum par, inshallha khuda tuhme kahi andha na karde.
    musalman ko nam raktha hai, kya janta

    ReplyDelete
  22. aap jo bhi boola wo thik nahi hain kyu ki har dharm main har trha kay log reha te hain asha khana ki islam aatank ko badawa de reha hain yegalt hain har dharm main har trha kay log hain kya pata jin logi ne asha kiya un ki koi majburi ho yaar wo sahi ho ham glat hain.ya wo galt hain ham sahi hain ye sab god kay uper hi chod de na hain ham ko.ham ko bas aps main pyar pyar or pyar rakhna hain is main aap ko or apni sari duniya ha auccha hain

    ReplyDelete
  23. Anonymous4:06 PM

    Hi to All!!

    Neither i am Hindu Nor i am Muslim.,i am just a human being created by god.Why people are bothered about Religon,instead of wasting your energy on criticism why don't you think in right direction..Dunia mein khali haath aye ho aur khaali haath jana hai.Hindus aur Muslim bhai bhai hain aur bhaiyon mein chhote mote jhagde hona jayaz hai.Boond Boond se sagar banta hai agar har nagrik ki soch ko badal diya jaye to wo din door nahin jab sab milkar Diwali aur ID manayenge.I have no problem reading Quran or Purans coz Moral is same dat "Its important to be nice than nice to be important".
    Please leave your comments if you appreciate my concern.

    ReplyDelete
  24. Indian3:05 PM

    Yaaro Kisi Ko Kuch badalne ki zarorat nahi hain, Khud ko badal lo....Sabse pyar karo fir woh koi bhi ho hindu ya muslim...Muslim se Salaam Karo aur Hindu Se Ram Ram, Koi Bura Hain to usse nafrat na karo uske liye Bhagwan se dua karo ke, Hey Ishwar woh jo bura hain woh bura na rahe..ek achha insaan bane jo sabse pyar kare..har ek k liye Achhe achhe kaam kare....Aao aaj kuch aisa kare ki Ab se Hum eid bhi manaye aur diwali bhi....Sab ek ho jaao..fir dekho k zindgee kitni khubsurat ho gayi hain....Meri Ishwar se aap sab ke liye dua hain ki aapsab ek dosre se itna pyaarkare itna pyaar kare ki nafrat k liye zara si bhi jahag na rahe...Ishwar aap sab ko buhat buhat buhat buhat khushi de jo aap aur logo ko bante.....Khush rahe..

    Indian...

    ReplyDelete
  25. Manoj6:14 AM

    PLZ STOP IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Please stop write comments hier.

    Yahan koi solution nahin nikalega, badle main Hindustaniyon main Hindu aur Musalman ko lekar ladai ho jayegi. Main nahin janata Hindu kaon hai aur Muslim kaon. We are only Indians. Never say "I am Hindu or I am Musalim". Say I am Indian. We are Indian. Yahin to chahte hain sab, Lado aur ek doosare ko maaro. Main to "PRATIK" ko bolata hoon, kya jaroorat hai aisa Artikel likhane ki. Ab dekha kya results de rahe hain sab log.

    Achha lagta hai kya yeh sab padhkar.

    I am not Gandhi. I also hate terriorist, phir chahe woh koi bhi ho. Even Cristien or Sikh bhi.

    Plz aise comment mat likho, jise padhkar kisi ko bura lage aur uske dil main, hum logon ke liye nafarat ki bhawana ho.

    PLZ STOP IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
  26. Manoj6:17 AM

    PLZ STOP IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    PLZ STOP IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    PLZ STOP IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    PLZ STOP IT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    PRATIK YOU SHOULD NOT WROTE THESE TYPES OF COMMENT.

    WHO GAVE YOU RIGHTS TO PROVOKE PEOPLE.

    ReplyDelete
  27. aapne islam ko samajhne me bhari bhool ki hai...jo ise kattar mazhab ka tag de rahe hian ap. asal me islam ko modern world me samjha hi nai gaya theek se...islam shanti ka mazhab hai...islam ke meaning agar ap dekhein to hi samajh jayenge ...islam ka matlab hota hia...jisme salamti ho...yani jisme surakhsha ho. islam esa mazhab hai..jisme insano ko unke basic rights diye gayehian..aj jo human right ke nam par halla mach raha hai islam to 1400 saal se bhi pehle human rights tey kar chuk ahi jise uske manne walo par zaruri hai..yahan tak ki islam janwaron ko bhi haq deta hai...ki unke sath kesa bartaw kiya jaye...aurton ke sath behave ko lekar...islam ko bohot badnam kiya jata rha haia..haqiqat to ye hai ki islam akela esa mazhab hai..jisne aourton ko haq diye...jese shadi ke liye uski razamandi zaruri hai ...aur usko mehar lene ka haq diya...usko ma baap ki jaydad me se hissa lene ka haq diya..islam to ye kehta hai ki bina kisi sahi wajah ke agar kisi ek insan ko jan se mar diya to wo hatya sari insaniyat ki hatya ke barabar hai..esa mazhab kattar ho sakta hai? aur jo ye kehta ho ki tum tab tak sachhe muslim nai ho sakte jab tak ki apne padosi ka dhyan na rakho...uske sath acha salook na karo...islam ko badalne ki bat karna moorkhta ke siwa kuch nai...ye sab isliye kaha ja rha hai ki aj islam ko manne wale uske basic rules ko aur uski shiksha ko jante nai hain..agar jante hain to theek se mante nai hain..follow nai kar rahe hain..aur kuch log raste se bhatak gaye hain...jinki wajh se sare muslim badnam ho rahe hain..kuch musllims ke terrorist ho jane par ap sare muslims ko badalne ki bat karte hian? pehle ap islam ko jan lein...to acha rahega.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Anonymous9:02 AM

    tum islma ko negative sochte ho positively socho and dekho ki kyo itne kum samaye me 1400 salo me puri duniya me islam faila hua hai yah kishi admi ka apna bnaaya hua dharam nahi hai yah allah ka bnaya hua hai "ki hamne tumhare liye islam ko mukkamal kar diya hai" Terrorist ki bat karte ho to Bhagat Singh, Rajguru ko kya kahoge. Muslmano ke to puri Duniya Dushman hai per sach(truth)hamiysa fail ke rahta hai islam jaisa pavitra religion koi nahi hai

    Apne doubt is website par padh le pls it all in hindi

    """ http://islaminhindi.blogspot.com/ """""""

    ReplyDelete
  29. Anonymous9:08 AM

    to understand or know islam in these website your doubt will be clear about islam

    http://www.islaminhindi.blogspot.com/
    http://www.harunyahya.com/
    http://www.chitthajagat.in/

    ReplyDelete
  30. har insan 2 type ka hota hai ek aacha or dusra bura islam ko manne wale bhi 2 prakar ke hote hai jo aache rehte hai vo aache muslman or jo bure vo aatankwadi. meri najro me islam ko bura nahi manna chahiye logo ko bura maanna chahi ye. aaj jaruri nahi muslman hindu se hi ladra ho aaj muslman2 ki ladai ho rhi hai hindu2 ki ladai ho rhi hai.hum jaise log kisi dharm ko bura nahi kehte uss dhrm ke logo ko bura kehte hai. mere hisab se islam bhut khatin dharm hai jise nibhana mere bas ki baat nahi hai.bharat me subhi muslamano ko hindu dhrm me collaboration ho jana chahiye kyuki hindu me koi jaat nahi hai esme kai jaatiya mili hui hai jise hindunsim kehte hai. agr esme ek or jaati mil jaehito koi frk nahi pdega.subhi tyohar saath me mil kar bnene me jyada khushi hogi. aacha nahi lgta jab 4 gharo me diwali ke diye jal rhe ho or ek ghr me andhera.

    ReplyDelete
  31. Anonymous3:32 AM

    ALLAH IS ONE

    ReplyDelete
  32. Anonymous7:16 AM

    In topic per bhi lekho
    1-why do not accept UN islamic rule for muslim of all over world
    2-why do not US attack on isrial for human right

    3-what you thing about reiliges law collibration

    ReplyDelete
  33. Anonymous1:02 AM

    First of all, Islam dont promote terrorism, secoud people dnt knw the basic of islam whether it is muslim of india or non muslim of India.

    Quran & Islam principle nobody is following,thats why this problem exist. Muslim not aware of other religion n Non muslim not at all know abt even basic Islam.

    there are many terrorist organization like naxal,hindu fasict,isreal zionism,Irish one,LTTE,Babbar khalsa.India itself have 45 terrorist organisation active like Bodo,Assam one etc

    My point terrorist dnt have any religion. Islam teaches peace n forgive.How many of know abt crusades,conquest of makka,godlen age of india,center point of knowledge was Sapein n Bagdhad where muslim have forgiven there enemy despite of they oppresse n touture.

    Well,in 26/11 many muslim died n its mumbai muslim who not ready to buried them.As terrorist cannot be muslim. Islam means peace ,so there is nothing called islamic terrorism.

    Plz called them with thier name e.g Let,taliban ,plz dont associate with Islam.

    Well people love blame game,to blame each other so that peace will never happen, apna ullooo kasie bhi sidha karna hai , old indian proverb.

    Majab nahi sikata aapase mei bair rakhna,hindi hai hum vatan hindusta humara

    ReplyDelete
  34. Anonymous4:49 PM

    No religion teach the lesson that you kill someone who is innocent or insult others, Religion is always very good but the followers can be bad. In Islam it is the same, Islam is the religion which teaches the lesson of good life. The Quran is not only the holy book but it is the rule of life. Quran is the Law for muslim. Quran never teaches to kill any innocent person. If any one come to kill you what you will do? you will not take defended for yourself. Quran teaches a muslim that he can defend himself and even Quran teaches that who is the real follower of Islam is the real muslim indeed. Don't ever think that Madrassa teaches wrong lessons to muslim. Madrassa teaches all the good thing which is necessary for the life of a muslim. Quran teaches that if your parents reaches old age, donot tell them even 'oh'. Quran teaches that a real follower of Islam is Muslim men and Muslim women, believing men and believing women, devout men and devout women, truthful men and truthful women, patient men and patient women, humble men and humble women, and the men who give Sadaqah (charity) and the women who give Sadaqah, and the men who fast and the women who fast, and the men who guard their private parts (against evil acts) and the women who guard (theirs), and the men who remember Allah much and the women who remember (Him) – for them, Allah has prepared forgiveness and a great reward.‎ 35- Surah Ahzab.
    We have seen only one side of the Muslim but as it is truly said the other side of the Muslim which is shown by the Sufi.
    Now let me tell about Hinduism, how many Hindus are here in India that they know their religion very well. You people simply follow to your leaders of the political party. All are crying for atankwad that too Islamic atankwad. What are others like LTTE, Maowad, Naxalism who are killing security forces in hundreds and kill many innocent persons. Why Hindus not stand against the killing of muslim in the name of riot. Just take the history of riot from this internet only and you people will come to know that since independent how many muslim killed, rape and burn by the hindus, even hindu police killed many unarmed innocent muslims in the name of riot and in the name of encounter. Is this the teaching of hinduism. The hindu parties always cry that the muslim population are doubling because they can have four wives. Just find out the records from Registrar General of Census office that how many muslims have four wives and now tell me that how many hindu have two wives. Just find out how many muslim home has more than two children and how many hindu home has more than two children.
    If the Vishwa Hindu Parishad and Bajrang Dal are saying that killed all the muslims in India, whether they are showing their true mentality of Hinduism or a sign of mental illness and those Hindus who follow them, What are they?
    How many hindus are there in the police department and other Govt. department and how many muslims are there in the Govt. department and in the police department. Just don't follow your politicians blindly, find out the facts yourself and then take the decision if you are true hindu.

    ReplyDelete

Related Posts with Thumbnails